ASCOTT RESIDENCE TRUST, daiwa maintain HOLD with target price $0.66
-Diversification offset by global downturn. We maintain our 3 (Hold) rating
for ART. The unit prices of hospitality-related S-REITs including ART were
highly resilient in June even though there were no signs, in our opinion,
that the decline in tourism or business travel had stabilised.
- We are cautious on the hospitality sector due to the poor visibility of
revenue-per-available-unit (RevPAU) and earnings during this global
business, investment and tourism slump. Although ART’s serviced-residence
portfolio is diversified by geography, while its customer profile includes
a good mix of industries and purposeof- stay (for business, leisure,
relocation, or project), we believe its operations would be affected
adversely by a prolonged recovery.
-Possibility of equity fundraising. Out of a total share of debt of
S$635.8m as at 31 March 2009, ART had refinancing requirements of S$111.6m
(18%) for FY09, S$10.5m (2%) for FY10, S$398.5m (62%) for FY11, and
S$115.2m (18%) for FY12. With a gearing ratio of 38.7% (based on a
proportionate share of debt and asset value) as at 31 March, we believe an
equity-fundraising exercise cannot be ruled out, given the recent track
record of CapitaLand-related S-REITs.
-Target price S$0.66. We maintain our six-month target price of S$0.66,
based on our RNG-valuation method, derived from capitalising ART’s
projected FY10 operating distribution (at an average RevPAU of S$124/day)
and an effective cap-rate assumption of 7.0%. ART’s target price to latest
(March 2009) book value of S$1.51 is 0.44x.
CAPITACOMMERCIAL TRUST, daiwa maintain OUTPERFORM with target price $0.94
-Maintain 2 rating. We maintain our 2 (Outperform) rating. We still have a
positive view on office-sector S-REITs and believe a stabilisation of the
spot-rent decline could trigger another round of outperformance. CCT’s
rights issue has helped it to recapitalise, but has also diluted the
potentialvaluation upside, based on our forecasts.
-No more overhang. CCT’s S$823m (gross) one-for-one rights issue, announced
on 22 May 2009, at S$0.59 per rights unit, has eliminated effectively, in
our view, the rights-issue overhang. .. With a post-rights issue leverage
ratio of 30.7%, which captures a 10% asset-value decline (based on 22 May
valuations), CCT is now one of the most well-capitalised S-REITs, in our
view.
-Well-positioned for refinancing challenges. CCT has no debt-financing
requirements for 2009, a S$650m (25%) secured term loan and a S$235m (9%)
medium-term note (MTN) for 2010, and S$520m (20%) in CMBS (for Raffles
City), a S$100m (4%) MTN, and S$370m (14%) of convertible bonds for 2011.
-Target price S$0.94. We maintain our RNG-valuation-method-derived target
price of S$0.94, based on capitalising CCT’s estimated FY08 core operating
distribution (at an average passing rent of S$6.84/sq ft/month) at an
effective cap-rate assumption of 6.5%. CCT’s target price to post-rights
(pro-forma) BVPS of S$1.51 is 0.62x.
CAPITALAND, daiwa upgrade to OUTPERFORM from HOLD with target price $4.22
-Rating upgraded to 2 from 3. We have upgraded our rating to 2 (Outperform)
from 3 (Hold) and expect the successful resumption of monetising portions
of its China-mall portfolio into CRCT, possibly with other
capitalproductive announcements, to trigger share-price outperformance.
-So far so good. CapitaLand’s business is diversified across several
property segments and geographic locations. With the possible exception of
the China market, property markets are generally subdued compared with
conditions before the global financial crisis, although the risk of a
property-market collapse has been averted.
-Singapore residential could be a 2010 story. Singapore property risks are
receding rapidly, and the magnitude of possible impairment charges for
certain projects in CapitaLand’s landbank are also diminishing. If the
propertymarket momentum carries strongly into 2010 (we believe this is
highly uncertain), CapitaLand might take significant market share with the
successful launch (or re-launch) of its mid-to-high end projects. Landbank
replenishment is an issue, but this would be adequately addressed if the
company were to acquire attractive sites (part of the capital-productive
announcements).
-Target price S$4.22. We have raised our six-month target price to a 60%
premium to NAV (from NAV and a target price of $$2.43 previously), one
standard deviation above the average premium to NAV, on our revised NAV
estimate of S$2.64.
CAPITALAND, db maintain SELL with target price $2.83
-Capitaland held a preview of Latitude (a 127-unit upper-mid freehold
project in River Valley) over the weekend, reducing prices by >30% to S
$1,600-1,700psf onwards. They previously sold 11 units at end 2007 at S
$2,400-2,800psf. No firm take-up figures have been released as yet (the
showflat had a moderate crowd), but the large unit sizes (2 BR from
1,300sf, 3BR up to 2,000sf) and absolute prices (> S$3.5m for the 3BR)
suggests slower take-up rates. Margins remain comfortable at >30% after the
prices cut due the low land cost. Recall, the group has sold around 90% of
Wharf Residences in May after cutting prices by around 20% to ~S$1,200psf.
Capl may launch Urban Resort in the coming months (est breakeven of S
$1,940psf).
-We see greater risk of landbank provisions for sites purchased later in
the cycle such as Char Yong Garden (breakeven est at S$2650psf) and Farrer
Court (breakeven est at S$1400psf), these could come through in the 2Q
results. In addition, Capitaland will be valuing investment properties
under development half-yearly (due to revisions in FRS40), similar to its
completed investment property portfolio. We see risk of write-downs and
revaluation deficits in the upcoming 2Q09 results, which will be partially
offset by revaluation gain from ION Orchard.
-In the absence of revaluation gains which boost headline earnings,
increasing focus is likely to fall on high multiples on weak recurring
PATMI. We maintain our Sell rating with valuations looking expensive at 8%
premium to RNAV and 41x FY09E PER on core earnings.
CAPITAMALL TRUST, daiwa maintain UNDERPERFORM with target price $1.32
-Maintain 4 rating. We maintain our 4 (Underperform) rating for CMT, and
believe there is still a high degree of uncertainty over how the trend for
retail sales (down 11.7% YoY for April) will play out over the remainder of
the year (we are not so sure that the worst is over), or how the rollout of
new retail supply would affect the operations or pricing power of existing
malls.
-Two major risks. We see CMT’s two major earnings-related risks as 1)
falling market rents and the start of a negative rental-reversion phase,
and 2) the implementation of concessionary rent cuts to keep retailers
afloat under a prolonged retail-sales slump.
-Not totally suburban. Suburban malls make up the core of CMT’s portfolio,
but it also owns The Atrium (an office property on Orchard Road acquired at
the peak of the market and with considerable asset-value downside, in our
view), a 40% stake in Raffles City, and Plaza Singapura. Even though Plaza
Singapura is not high-end, we see a considerable amount of new retail space
on Orchard Road catering to a similar (youth and lifestyle) market,
especially at Orchard Central.
-Target price S$1.32. We maintain our six-month target price, based on our
RNGvaluation method, of S$1.32, obtained from capitalising the estimated
FY09 core operating distribution at an effective caprate assumption of
7.0%. CMT’s target price to latest (March 2009) book, adjusted for the
rights issue, of S$1.66, is 0.80x.
CAPITARETAIL CHINA TRUST, daiwa upgrade to OUTPERFORM from UNDERPERFORM
with target price $1.32($1)
-Rating upgraded to 2 from 4. We have upgraded our rating for CRCT to 2
(Outperform) from 4 (Underperform) and expect a resumption of acquisitions
from CapitaLand’s China-mall pipeline to improve its DPU-growth outlook and
trigger further unit-price outperformance. Based on our new acquisition
assumptions and revised estimates, we forecast CRCT’s industry-leading DPU
CAGR (FY08-11) to increase to 9.0% (from 8.4%).
-Waiting to pull the trigger. We believe the strong unit-price performance
so far in 2009 has allowed the manager to set its sights again on
acquisitions. Assuming that positive unit-price momentum can be sustained,
we now believe CRCT can launch a successful acquisition and
equity-fundraising deal that would be accretive for unitholders.
-Minor refinancing risk. CRCT has a S$65.2m (15.5% of total debt) unsecured
offshore loan due in FY09, a S$288.5m (68.7%) unsecured, fixed-rate,
offshore loan due in FY10, and a S$66.3m (15.8%) onshore loan due in FY11.
-Target price S$1.32. We have raised our target price, based on our
RNG-valuation method, to S$1.32 (from S$1.00). We have capitalised the
portfolio’s estimated FY10 (previously FY09) core operating distribution at
an effective cap-rate assumption of 6.0% (from 7%). CRCT’s target price to
latest (March 2009) book of S$1.24 is 1.06x.
CHINA HONGXING, db maintain BUY with target price $0.22
-We hosted China Hongxing’s management in Singapore last week and continue
to see encouraging signs that the operating environment is improving. Here
our key takeaways from the meetings
-Trend in operating performance continues to improve. Inventory levels have
been reduced to three months in Jun 09, from four months in May 09 and the
peak of five months in Feb 09. In addition, management has a target for
inventory levels to come down to around two months by the 3Q09. While the
company’s SSS for Jun 09 have been flat, we believe this is due to the high
base effect from the Beijing Olympics in Jun/Jul 08. The company is looking
to reinstate its dividend payout this year (historically has paid out both
an interim and final dividend).
-Focus on spending 20% of A&P on sponsorship. The company is starting its
marketing campaign with a five year sponsorship deal with the Shanghai
Masters Series Organising Committee to be the official apparel partner for
the Association of Tennis Professionals (ATP) - Shanghai Masters in the
second half of 2009. This marketing campaign will help profile China
Hongxing’s brand, Erke, and help to increase its brand awareness amongst
Chinese consumers.
-Upbeat on Aug 09 trade fairs sales. If the operating environment continues
to improve, we believe this could lead to possible turnaround in Aug 09
trade fair sales. Signs of an improvement in the cash conversion cycle,
higher operating cash flows, continued repayments from its distributors
could be key catalysts for the stock to rerate.
CITY DEV, dbs maintain BUY with target price $10.67($10.55) EPS for FY09/10
raised by 8.1% and 9.9%
-A Stamp of Confidence. Attracting one of the strongest client interests at
our ‘Pulse of Asia conference, City Dev stamped its confidence in the
demand fundamentals underlying the mass and mid-tier residential market,
even if the high-end segment may take a couple more quarters before seeing
a re-ignition of interest. It continues to be business as usual for City
Dev, as it readies new launches with an array of projects catering to every
market segment.
-Something For Every Appetite. Having already sold 500 units in 1H09, it is
poised to sell another 500 units in 2H09. On the menu are high-end Volari
in Jul/Aug (former Garden Hotel at Balmoral Road), a mass-mid market
project at the former Hong Leong Garden in Sep, and two mass-market sites –
The Gale in July (33% stake, at Upper Changi) and another Pasir Ris project
at year-end. And if buying appetites aren’t sufficiently sated, high-end
Quayside at Sentosa is launch-ready.
-BUY, 27% Upside to TP of S$10.67. After adjusting ASPs for Hong Leong
Garden and marking-to-market its listed entities, our RNAV is revised up to
S$8.90 (from S$8.79). We keep a 20% premium on the stock, which is close to
historical +1SD levels, for a TP of S$10.67 (prev S$10.55) giving a 27%
upside. Reiterate BUY on our top big-cap pick for the property developers.
COMFORTDELGRO, jpm maintain OVERWEIGHT with target price $2
-Earnings pick-up on track We see earnings return to normalized levels in
2009 on lower fuel prices. Earnings contribution has also begun at
ComfortDelgro Cabcharge Victoria (formerly Kefford) post acquisition. This
was faster than expected and the segment’s high operating margin of 23% is
likely to be accretive to the Group’s overall bus business (1Q09 bus EBIT
margin 8.5%) in the long-run.
-Still the market leader in taxis ComfortDelgro continues to maintain its
leadership position in the Singapore taxi business with a market share of
63%. Its idle rate of a low 1.5% also sets it markedly ahead of its close
competitor – SMRT – although we observe keen competition from private
operator TransCab which is fast catching up with the second largest market
share.
- Quiet on the M&A front so far The current economic conditions should have
presented significant M&A opportunities for a wellmanaged land transport
group like ComfortDelgro, as some companies may be facing distress but
still holding potentially lucrative operating concessions. However, we have
yet to see any M&As from the company YTD, possibly attributed to
management’s cautious stance.
- Undemanding valuation, in need of strong positive catalysts There could
be a potential shortage of near-term catalysts for the stock given
management’s conservative stance as far as M&As are concerned. We remove
the stock from the Asia Analysts’ Focus List. Nonetheless, valuation
remains undemanding at 12x FY10E P/E and 1.6x P/B and we continue to
believe that its 75%-owned SBS Transit stands a relatively higher chance in
securing the Downtown MRT line to be awarded early 2010.
OLAM, cl maintain BUY with target price $2.59 EPS for FY09/10 raised by
26.5% and 5.4%
-Our checks with Management suggest improving demand, especially in the
industrials segment, making us sanguine on Olam meeting CLSA’s ahead of
Street expectations for 4Q09. Together with expanding intracountry trade,
we expect this momentum to continue through FY10. The recent share
placement heralds a comeback of the Group’s acquisitions strategy. Hence,
we raise our M&A valuation weighting in our DCF and peer based target price
from 5% to 20% deriving a TP of S$2.59 implying 16% upside to the S$2.24
theoretical ex-placement price. BUY.
-4Q09 on-track to meet our expectations. Olam’s industrial soft commodities
segment saw a 16% volume contraction in 3Q09. Since then, Management is
seeing an improvement in Asian demand. For cotton, the Group is
experiencing higher demand from South and East Asia. In coffee, Olam has
successfully doubled its market share in Brazil. In dairy and cocoa, the
demand profile remains weak with continued de-stocking seen for the latter
in the EU and US. The key here is that the Group managed to grow overall
volumes by 6% YoY in 3Q09 during the worst phase of global demand
destruction. Continued improvement throughout 4Q09 makes us sanguine of
Olam’s ability to meet our ahead of Street earnings expectations.
-Positive momentum to continue through FY10. The Group plans to expand its
intra-country strategy in India and China along with Africa and Latin
America. Add to this a bigger contribution from past acquisitions.
Management reiterates their 16-20% YoY volume growth guidance for FY10. It
must be noted that barring FY07 volume growth has exceeded top-end guidance
by 4-11% hence earnings risk is on the upside.
-Acquisitions for next leg up. Olam’s acquisition strategy is making a
comeback post their Temasek placement. We believe this will result in a
significant (~25% of assets) and imminent acquisition. Historically, the
Group has been successful in exploiting market inefficiencies from
investing in assets with potential for above normal profits. Given Olam’s
global presence we expect this deal to be of similar.
-Upgrading target price to S$2.59. With the launch of their acquisition
strategy we raise the M&A scenario weighting from 5% to 20% in our DCF and
peer valuation based target price to derive a TP of S$2.59. This implies a
16% upside to the current theoretical ex-placement price of S$2.24. Trading
at 20x 12-month forward PE vs. a long term average of 23x, we remain BUYers
of Olam.
OLAM, db downgrade to SELL with target price $2 EPS for FY0910 lowered by
5.6% and 16.9%
-Good news discounted with share price run-up. Olam has outperformed the
STI following its recent placement to Temasek (273m new shares at S$1.60)
and the acquisition of SK Foods (US$39m). We believe much of the good news
has been discounted after the share price surge. At 23x FY10E PER, 3.3x
P/B, and 11.4x EV/EBITDA, Olam is not only trading at a sizeable premium to
its peers, but it is expensive versus itsown trading history. Sell.
-EPS dilution/contribution disconnect; M&A risk. We believe Olam’s share
price strength comes largely from the hope of M&A activities and potential
contributions from Temasek. This anticipation, we feel, has been
overplayed, and the earnings dilution/contribution disconnect (i.e.,
immediate EPS dilution from the placement vs. the earnings lag from new
acquisitions) shows that much has been discounted with the high valuations.
M&A, while exciting, could raise overall risk as the number ofmoving parts
increases.
-Company visit; April/May 2009 volume surge not sustained. Our recent
company visit indicates that the volume surge seen by the group in
April/May ‘09 was due largely to Chinese re-stocking and has not been
sustained. Cotton demand has slightly declined in June, and the outlook is
weak. Wool and rubber remain weak due to continued poor consumer spending.
Cocoa and dairy, which are said to be recession-resistant, are also showing
slight weakness.
-Downgrade to Sell; EPS lowered after factoring in placement. Our target
price of S$2.00 is based on the Gordon Growth method and has been raised
after factoring in the recent share placement. Assumptions ROE of 19%, a
long-term growth rate of 3% and COE of 10%. Upside risks include
better-thanexpected volumes in its products, market share gains and new
products.
SEMBCORP MARINE, kim eng maintain HOLD with target price $2.73($2.31)
-Raising recommendation to a Hold. With the resolution of the PetroRig I
sale, we are raising our recommendation on Sembcorp Marine (SMM) to a Hold.
However, the outlook for rig newbuilds still remains muted at this point,
and we remain unexcited over its medium term prospects.
-SMM recovers amounts due from PetroRig I. On June 8, SMM had announced
that it had sold the semisubmersible PetroRig I to Diamond Offshore in
order to recover monies due to them following the non-payment by the
customer, Petromena. Diamond has disclosed a price of around US$460, of
which SMM will receive its outstanding amount of US$200, plus
administrative costs. The balance of the amount will be returned to the
original bondholders of the project.
-SMM risk controls working. With the healthy reported selling price of
US$460m, this assuages concerns of SMM’s other 2 rigs being built under the
same specifications for Petromena. SMM has collected 50% of these contracts
amounts, and believes that it would be able to dispose of the rigs in a
similar manner at no loss if Petromena should once again default on
payment. The sale also indicates that demand for such deepwater rigs
remains healthy, and that SMM is able to protect itselfagainst such default
contingencies.
-Deepwater interest still not translating to orders. However, despite
continued interest in the deepwater segment, we do not see this translating
to significant orders, despite an improving credit environment. SMM’s last
reported orderbook stood at $8.4b stretching to 2012, and has since
announced orders worth S$230m for an offshore platform contract for SMOE,
as well as US$237m outfitting and completion order for a semisubmersible.
-Raising SOTP target to S$2.73. We are raising SMM’s price target to $2.73
from $2.31 previously, on higher shipyard multiples in our sum-of-the-parts
valuation. Our FY09 net profit forecast of $497m remains unchanged. While
2-yr earnings CAGR is still a healthy 12.7% p.a., we expect turnover to
taper off from 2011 onwards. While we do expect the rig market to pick up,
we are unlikely to see the same strength as in the last boom cycle between
2005 and 2008. However, given its respectable earnings visibility and
decent dividend yield, we raise the stock to a Hold.
SIA, jpm upgrade to OVERWEIGHT from NEUTRAL with target price $14($9.40)
-Upgrade to OW SIA is in its worst earnings cycle in history with a high
probability of reporting losses for the next two quarters which explains
its underperformance versus the market year-to-date. Although we remain
bearish on the near term outlook and the timing and quality of the rebound
remains uncertain, we believe that its potential correction in the upcoming
results and/or the worsening impact from Influenza A would provide a good
opportunity to accumulate in preparation for a cyclical upturn. For more
risk averse investors, SIA is also the “safest” choice in the sector given
its well-capitalized balance sheet, strong track record at managing costs
during downturns and ability to unlock more value from
subsidiaries/associates such as SIE, Tiger Air in the longer term, and M&A
forays that could lift market sentiment even though they may not
necessarily be value-enhancing.
-Potential longer-term value in SATS Stock is effectively trading cum
dividend of S$1.77/share. Buying SIA now entitles shareholders to 0.73 SATS
share for every 1 SIA share. Although shareholders may not necessarily
realize the value of SATS near term due to potential share overhang as free
float would rise from 19% to 45%. However, applying mid-cycle airport
valuations on SATS of c.18x P/E would imply a potential fair value of
c.S$2.40/share longer term.
- Long-term prospects SIA is one of the best-managed airlines with strong
pricing power and a highly efficient cost structure in our view. It is also
the only Asian airline with a net cash balance and has been returning more
capital to shareholders in recent years. However, we believe SIA is a
mature airline with more limited growth prospects than Cathay and its
market share at its home base should gradually diminish as low cost carrier
penetration grows. We see risks entering M&A deals that may not be
value-enhancing.
- PT, valuation, key risks We have raised our PT to factor in SIA’s
improving earnings outlook in the next 12 months. Our ex-div Jun 2010 PT of
S$14 is based on 1.2x P/BV, SIA’s average valuation since 2003 when its
competitive environment intensified with the entry of low cost carriers and
Emirates’ increased presence in Singapore. Key risks 1) WHO issues travel
restrictions due to Influenza A, 2) stagflation, 3) making value-destroying
investments.
SINGTEL, ml maintain BUY with target price $3.33($3.08)
-PO raised 8% on FY11E rollover; earnings raised by 6-7%. We raise our PO
8%, to S$3.33/shr and FY10-12E earnings by 6-7%. The earnings upgrade is
led by margin uplift (~1.5ppt) at Optus & update to FX assumptions. We
expect FY11E earnings growth to accelerate to 7% as steady momentum in core
markets (~4% EBITDA growth) finds support from Assoc earnings recovery.
-Revitalized core mkts., low-price stub to offset M&A jitters. We like
SingTel for its dominance in S’pore & improving subscriber market share of
Optus. Stub valuations are at ~10% discount to int’l peers on FY11E
EV/EBITDA (5.6x). We recognize worries over potential cash outgo towards
Bharti-MTNbut believe this will not stress the balance sheet or dividend
outgo.
-Involvement in Bharti-MTN may rise; FY11E dividend safe. Retention of
SingTel’s current proportion of board representation at Bharti and ease of
equity accounting for the Bharti in a post-MTN transaction scenario appear
to be key issues for SingTel as it evaluates the MTN deal. We think SingTel
could look at ways to raise its stake in Bharti possibly through buy-out of
MTN’s minorities. Assuming SingTel keeps net debt/EBITDA between 1.5-2x and
maintains FY11E dividend payout at 57%, we see room for up to US$3bn outgo
that would raise SingTel’s post-MTN Bharti stake to ~25%. Consequently,
earnings could see a potential ~3% uplift but ROIC would fall ~200bps.
-Optus keen on NBN rollout but equity participation not easy. Rollout of
the proposed A$43bn NBN project would expand Optus’ access to markets &
offers potential business upside. However, equity participation in the NBN
project may be difficult unless the govt. prefers to absorb Optus’ HFC
network in areas that overlap with Telstra’s network. Any equity raising
through relisting Optus also seems unlikely as it could trigger an
impairment charge.
SMRT, jpm maintain NEUTRAL with target price $1.80
- Circle Line ridership could surprise on the upside The Circle Line (CCL)
attracted a daily ridership of about 30,000 – 35,000 during its first week
of operations since the 5-station, phase 3 of the 29-station lines opened
in May 2009. This is better than our estimate of 25,000. The remaining
phases will be opened from 2010. With the CCL being a transfer line”
cutting across the other lines, it should be able to capture a good amount
of ridership share.
- Might be net beneficiary of centralized bus planning SMRT’s bus network
currently spans the less densely populated areas of Singapore. The LTA is
in the process of re-planning the whole bus network under its centralized
bus planning exercise. SMRT could emerge a net beneficiary from this
exercise, as routes get redistributed so that it could have a chance of
securing the more lucrative bus services.
-Retail space rental earnings could see slower growth Retail space rental
experienced phenomenal growth in the past on the back of aggressive
refurbishment of existing stations and the conversion of bigger underground
stations into “Xchanges” housing more retail shops. Going forward, we
believe that the growth from this segment could plateau as the CCL is fully
underground and the stations are smaller, translating to less lettable
retail space. This segment currently contributes about 23% of SMRT’s
operating profits and is the second largest profit contributor after the
core MRT business.
- Valuation, risks At 15.4x FY10E P/E, we believe the stock is fairly
valued, trading above its historical mean forward P/E of 13.5x. Upside
risks could come from the CCL breaking even faster than the FY 2013E in our
assumption.
ST ENGINEERING, uob maintain SELL with target price $2.04
-Listing of the notes could see interest shift to notes at the expense of
the stock. STE pays out 98-100% of its earnings and the higher debt (+92%)
could affect dividend payout.
-Corporate Events. ST Engineering (STE) has announced that it has set up a
financial subsidiary, ST Engineering Financial 1 Ltd (STEF-1), which will
be issuing US$1.2b multi-currency denominated medium term notes and has
applied for listing of such notes on the SGX. The notes have been rated AAA
by S&P. The proceeds will be used to refinance existing borrowings and fund
new capex and acquisitions.
-Stock Impact. A pre-emptive note issue? STE has indicated that it is
taking a pre-emptive measure to diversify its funding options and will be
opting for a multi-currency denominated medium term note. As at 1Q09, STE
had S$913m in debt and S$1.39b in cash and near cash, of which S$599.9m is
placed with Fullerton Fund Management, a wholly-owned unit of Temasek
Holdings. The US$1.2b notes will raise debt by 92%, assuming the new debt
will be used to refinance existing debts. In 2008, the effective cost of
debt was just 4.8% and had eased further in 1Q09. The 6.75% interest cost
is shown net of fair value of an interest rate swap trade. Assuming the
note has a coupon of 4.5%, interest cost willbe S$78.8m, or 84.6% higher
than in 2008.
-Borrowings seem high relative to annual capex requirement.Over the last
three years, maintenance capex amounted to about 131% of depreciation costs
(S$159m in 2008) and slightly more than half of capex was directed towards
the aerospace segment. STE has already made substantial investments in
China, with new hangars coming on stream in Shanghai and Xiamen in 2009.
Thus, the need for further funding comes as a surprise.
-Earnings Risk/Recommendation. The incremental funding will be the largest
in nine years and is expected to raise interest expense and potentially
affect dividend payout. We also believe STE’s dividend yield should reflect
a risk premium over the coupon on the note. Pending further announcements,
we are neutral on the stock. We maintain our SELL recommendation and our
fair price of S$2.04, which is based on 14x two-year forward earnings.
STRAITS ASIA, ubs remains a BUY with target price $2.50(from $2.80)
- We maintain our Buy rating for Straits Asia following our revised coal
price estimate for 2010-13. We lower our price target from S$2.80 to S$2.50
as we increase our 2010 target PE from 8.4x to 12.7x following a lower
risk-free rate from 12.8% to 11.5% but lower our 2010 EPS estimate. We make
the following adjustments to our earnings estimate for Straits Asia.
- Coal price assumption revision. Our revised thermal coal price
assumptions accounts for 95% of the total net earnings revision. We
highlight that the effect on Straits Asia’s earnings is negative relative
to its peers as we have previously factored in a higher coal price to
account for high-priced contracts. This followed SAR’s US$230m refinancing
last year, as lenders required the company to contract future sales in
order to provide earnings security. However, in the meantime it has been
necessary to renegotiate select contracts in order to maintain customer
relationships. Consequently, we reduce our average selling price estimate
by 16% for 2009, while increasing our quality discount assumption slightly
to account for a higher production output from the lower calorific Jembayan
mine.
- Cost assumptions unchanged. We maintain our view that unit costs will
remain largely unchanged as our expected approval to mine SAR’s Sebuku
concession will reduce weighted average costs. The mine is a low-cost
operation due to its lower stripping (overburden) ratio and close proximity
to port.
- Growth in outstanding shares. We increase the total number of shares from
1,094m to 1,129m following a recent issue of warrants, which are now inthe-
money given the shares’ 140% increase since February 2009. The revision
accounts for around 5% of total net earnings changes.
WILMAR, ocbc maintain BUY with target price $5.78-Eyes HK Listing for China Ops. Wilmar International (Wilmar) has confirmed
that it has hired three investment banks to “evaluate” the feasibility of a
HK listing; it had previously unveiled such plans to list 20-30% of its
China operations in either HK or China to tap investor interest in its
biggest market and to raise cash for acquisitions. In an earlier Reuters
report citing unnamed sources, it said that the IPO - worth around US$3b -
is set for a listing late this year or early next year. In FY08, its China
business turned in revenue of US$14.3b (49% of overall sales) and an
estimated US$500m to its bottom line. Assets in China amounted to US$6.5b,
or nearly 40% of its total assets (Exhibit 1).
-Limited impact from lower CPO prices. Meanwhile, CPO (crude palm oil)
futures in KL have recently hit a 13-week low, with the actively traded Sep
contract falling 6.1% last week, unsettled by concerns of more bearish news
on the horizon. The most worrying is the further deterioration of the
fundamentals for the crop - industry watchers warned that the CPO stockpile
could surge going into the high production period as foreign demand has
been poor. However, we do not expect lower CPO prices to have much of a
negative impact on the group although revenue may fall (mainly due to its
palm and lauric business). On the other hand, a significant downstream
player such as Wilmar may benefit from lower feedstock prices as it still
sources around 60% of its requirements from third party plantation
companies. In any case, we note that Wilmar has shown a consistent ability
to manage the price fluctuations (see Exhibit 2), often riding out the
volatility with aplomb.
-Maintain BUY with S$5.78 fair value. The latest news shows that the
proposed HK listing of its China operations is on track. Based on its
estimated US$500m bottom-line contribution, we believe that the US$3b
flotation is not an issue, assuming a valuation of 20x and a divestment of
30%. However, we will hold off adjusting our numbers until we get more
information about the structure and form of the proposed listing.
Nevertheless, we are bumping up our valuations slightly from 18x blended
FY09/10 PER to 18.5x, deriving a fair value of S$5.78. Maintain our BUY
rating.
WINGTAI, dbs upgrade to BUY from HOLD with target price $1.56($1.54)
-Blue or Grey Sky? At our conference, client interest in Wing Tai mainly
centered on its upcoming launch of Ascentia Sky, which is expected to enter
the market this week. Our channel checks indicate ASPs post-discount
starting from around S$1,100 psf onwards for the 373- unit project.
Following recent market trends, the project has been reconfigured to
include a greater proportion (c.40% each) of 2 and 3 bedroom units. Our
current valuation is based on an ASP of S$1,200 psf for Ascentia Sky, which
is close to the 2007 peak achieved at nearby Metropolitan. As Wing Tai only
has a 40% stake, our sensitivity analysis indicates every S$100 psf
increase in ASP translates to a 0.5 Scent increase in RNAV.
-Room With A Vue. Wing Tai’s other 2009 offering for now is Belle Vue
Residences. A total of 79 units out of this 176-unit project have been
launched, with 61 units sold at between S$1,700-1,900 psf. More than 80% of
buyers are local. Around 80% of buyers have taken up the Deferred Payment
Scheme (DPS), possibly eyeing a quick flip as the project obtains TOP in a
year.
-Upgrade to BUY, TP S$1.56 gives 15% upside. Adjusting our ASP assumptions
for Ascentia to S$1,200 psf, our RNAV is revised to S$1.95 (from S$1.93).
We maintain our 20% discount to RNAV (between historical average and +1SD),
for a TP of S$1.56 (prev S$1.54). Upgrade to BUY, with 15% upside.
Accumulate this high-beta, purer residential play on expectations of
recovery filtering up to the high-end.
[ SECTOR ]
HDD by cimb
- Weak start to 2009, but Seagate and WD’s results still ahead of guidance.
Not surprisingly, the slowdown at end-2008 spilt over into early 2009,
resulting in overall HDD shipment contractions of 15% yoy and 8% qoq to
113m units. This marked the second consecutive quarter of qoq decline in
unit shipments for the HDD industry. Nevertheless, the two major drive
makers, Seagate and WD, still managed to deliver 1Q09 results that beat
their original guidance.
- 2Q09 results could be ahead of expectations. Our channel checks and
positive comments by Seagate and WD suggest that 2Q09 could again turn out
better than market expectations. We gather from most HDD component
suppliers that volume has continued to grow mom since end-1Q09 as the
contraction in demand has not been as severe as anticipated. Also, we
believe some rise in orders was due to restocking by OEMs and channel
partners.
- Tight control of production and inventories helps. We believe HDD OEMs’
good discipline in controlling output as well as healthy channel
inventories had helped in the past two quarters. Their proactive moves had
prevented an oversupply that could prolong the downturn.
- Seasonal strength on track? We gather from industry contacts that current
build plans for all major drive makers point to sequential volume growth of
8-17% in 3Q09. This suggests that the traditional seasonal strength in 2H09
is intact, in line with our assumption of a yoy recovery in volume from
4Q08, when orders in the sector nosedived as the global financial crisis
deepened.
- Risk slower-than-expected sell-through in 3Q09. We believe the key risk
for the sector is a slower-than-expected sell-through in 3Q, which may
result in a drop in orders in 4Q09, mirroring the case in 2008.
- Armstrong’s overall business has improved. Our last discussions with the
company suggest that business in most divisions has improved from a weak
1Q, especially HDD components in Singapore and the automotive business in
China. We believe Armstrong could return to yoy profit growth in 3Q09, in
the absence of huge forex losses.
- Broadway to benefit from recovery in HDD demand. Broadway should be the
main beneficiary of a recovery in HDD demand as it derives more than 70% of
its revenue from this sector. The stock is one of the cheapest among peers
and its historical trading experience.
- Cal-Comp’s improved HDD-related businesses may not be sufficient to
offset potential losses in HP printer business. Cal-Comp reported healthy
19% yoy revenue growth in the month of June, its first double-digit yoy
growth this year. Although we expect it to benefit from rising HDD demand,
its earnings could be hurt by changes in HP’s supply chain from 2H09
onwards.
- Upgrade from Underweight to Overweight. We upgrade the sector as we pass
the trough in 1Q09 and enter the seasonally stronger half. We see positive
news flow boosting trading interest in HDD component suppliers like
Broadway and Armstrong.
OIL by ms
-Overweight Cairn India (CAIL.BO), SK Energy (096770.KS), Woodside
(WPL.AU), Oil Search (OSH.AX) Underweight Sinopec (0386.HK )
-Crude Oil. Average prices for WTI for the week rose 0.5%; supply
disruptions in Nigeria supported the prices, however a stronger dollar saw
oil prices tapering off by the end of the week.
-Refining Margins. Complex margins average for the week fell 33% to
US$2.1/bb. Simple margins were negative at US$(0.7)/bbl.
-China has hiked the prices for gasoline, diesel, and kerosene (overall
hike 11%), however we believe this increase means Sinopec’s refining
division only breaks even.
-India also hiked retail prices for gasoline (Rs4/Litre) and diesel
(Rs2/Litre), keeping the prices of cooking fuels unchanged. Key
beneficiaries include the Upstream companies (ONGC and GAIL) and downstream
companies (HPCL, BPCL, and IOCL)
-Petrochemical Spreads. Ethylene-Naphtha gained strength, by 8.5%, however
HDPE-Naphtha fell by 1.4%
PROPERTY by ssb
- Prime office rents fall 19% in Q2 DTZ — Office rents in Raffles Place
fell 19% in the second quarter of this year, after sinking 25% in Q1,
according to a new report from DTZ. The average monthly gross rent for
prime office space in Raffles Place slipped to $9.70 psf pm in Q2. The
figure has now fallen close to the level at end- 2006 - and is 49% below
the Q3 2008 peak. Research from CB Richard Ellis (CBRE) shows the same
trend. Prime office rents averaged $8.60 psf pm in Q2 - an 18.2% qoq fall.
This was a slight moderation from the 18.6% drop in Q1. But CBRE and DTZ
say leasing enquiries are starting to pick up, though take-up is likely to
remain in negative territory for the rest of 2009 and occupancies are
expected to dip further.
- Industrial sector weakens further DTZ — Demand for private industrial
space continued to shrink in the second quarter of this year, says property
firm DTZ. And private industrial rents - in decline since Q4 2008 -
registered steeper falls in Q2 2009 than in the two preceding quarters.
Average monthly gross rent fell 6.8% for first-storey private industrial
space and 8.1% for upper-storey space in Q2 this year. This was the
sharpest contraction since Q3 2003. Amid lower demand in the industrial and
office markets, hi-tech industrial rents posted their biggest contraction
since Q2 2003, falling 12.8% in Q2 2009 to 24.4% below the peak in Q3 2008.
- Mapletree net profits shrink to $210m — Mapletree Investments saw net
profit plunge to $210.3 million for FY 008 ended March 31, 2009 from $1.04
billion a year earlier, on a sharp fall in revaluation gains. The company,
which is fully owned by Temasek Holdings, said in its latest annual report
that revaluation gains from investment properties fell from $1.09 billion
in FY 2007 to $36.1 million in FY 2008. This dragged profit down even
though revenue climbed on the back of higher rental income. Total revenue
rose 21.7% to $444.9 million, from $365.6 million in FY 2007.